Get Better Ingredients, Better Pizza when you use a Papa John's Gift Card. When you order from Papa John's, you get our fresh, never frozen, original dough, all natural-sauce, 100% real meats and fresh-sliced veggies. We think you'll taste the difference, because "Nobody does what Papa John's does." Gift card is redeemable by phone, in restaurants, and online. There are more than 3,200 restaurants in the U.S., including Alaska and Hawaii. No expiration and no service fees.